Tru Earth vs. Earth Breeze: Which Eco-Friendly Laundry Detergent is Best?

Published on October 3rd, 2023 by Brett Knighton

An infographic showing Tru Earth's and Earth Breeze's packaging with pricing information and showing a comparison between the two eco-friendly laundry detergent brands.

When it comes to finding the best eco-friendly alternative to traditional laundry detergents, there are two brands that stand out: Tru Earth and Earth Breeze. These companies produce affordable, non-toxic, environmentally friendly laundry detergent sheets that are still effective at cleaning clothes.

Laundry can be a never-ending task, especially for larger families. It can also be costly, as the amount of laundry detergent you use can quickly add up. This takes a toll on your wallet and has more potential to harm our environment because of the harsh chemicals commonly found in these products and their plastic packaging.

According to the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), only 9% of plastic waste globally is recycled properly. A staggering 50% of it ends up in landfills, and 22% doesn't even make it to waste management centers, littering our oceans and lands instead.

Because of this, eco-conscious consumers worldwide are looking to do their part to eliminate this waste.

With the global market for laundry detergent sheets projected to reach $2.5 billion USD by 2030, many companies have recognized this shift and have added new products to their lines.

However, Earth Breeze and Tru Earth have been pioneers in this market for years, remaining the top choices for consumers.

In this article, we'll compare the Tru Earth laundry strips and the Earth Breeze laundry sheets to determine which brand provides the best eco-friendly laundry detergent you can feel good about using.

Let’s get to it!

*Any product links are merely suggestions to help you, and we strive to give you the most eco-friendly options. We will earn a small commission when you purchase through referral links on our site.

What are Laundry Detergent Sheets?

Laundry detergent sheets are a sustainable alternative to traditional liquid or powder detergents. These thin, paper-like sheets are infused with concentrated detergent, offering a mess-free and eco-friendly solution to laundry cleaning.

Designed to dissolve easily in water, they release natural, plant-based cleaning agents that effectively tackle dirt and stains. Their lightweight and compact nature reduces the carbon footprint associated with transportation and eliminates the guesswork in measuring detergent quantities, preventing waste.

These sheets come in minimalistic, often biodegradable or recyclable packaging, significantly reducing plastic waste. They're formulated with gentle, non-toxic ingredients that are kind to your skin and the environment without compromising cleaning power.

Laundry detergent sheets are a convenient, eco-friendly choice for your modern laundry needs. They are compatible with standard and highly efficient washing machines, effective in hot and cold water, and save space.

Now that you understand the benefits of laundry detergent sheets, let's quickly compare Tru Earth's Eco-Strips and Earth Breeze's detergent sheets.

A Quick Comparison

Aspect Tru Earth Earth Breeze
Ingredients 16 Ingredients plus fragrance in their scented options 9 Ingredients plus essense for their fresh scent option
Scents Lilac Breeze, Fresh Linen, and Fragrance-Free Fresh Scent, Fragrance-Free
Price by Value $21.95 for 32 Strips (Subscription: $15.95 for 32 Strips)
Best Value: 384 Standard Strips $0.31/load
$20.00 for 30 Sheets (Subscription: $12.00 for 30 Sheets)
Best Value: $0.20/load
Usability Compatible with all washing machines, including HE, top-loading, and front-loading units; suitable for both hot and cold water usage Compatible with all washing machines, including HE, top-loading, and front-loading units; suitable for both hot and cold water usage
Packaging Plastic-free, Recyclable, and Compostable Cardboard Sleeve Plastic-free, Recyclable, and Compostable Cardboard Sleeve
Shipping Canada: Shipped from British Columbia and Ontario
US: Shipped from Washington, Utah, and Tennessee
Shipped from warehouses in Oregon and a local warehouse in the United Kingdom
Manufactured Made in Canada Made in China
Certifications Certified B Corporation OECD 301B - Ready Biodegradability
Biodegradable
Septic Safe
Cruelty-Free
Vegan
Shelf Life 36 months 18 months
Where to Order

An In-Depth Look at the Differences Between Tru Earth and Earth Breeze

In the comparison table above, you can see Tru Earth and Earth Breeze have a lot in common. But, as mentioned earlier, we're here to explore these products in more detail, highlighting even the smallest differences. This will help you choose the one that best suits your needs and aligns with your values.

Tru Earth vs Earth Breeze: Which Offers Better Eco-Friendly Ingredients?

When choosing the most eco-friendly laundry detergent, the ingredients should be your starting point. Both Tru Earth and Earth Breeze have pledged to keep their products free from harmful chemicals.

You won't find any parabens, phosphates, dyes, or bleach in their detergents, and they've both received a hypoallergenic stamp of approval, meaning they are gentle on your skin.

Tru Earth believes in complete transparency, listing all the ingredients used in their range of products on their website. While Earth Breeze doesn't share a detailed list on their website, you can find all the information you need on their product packaging.

Both brands use ingredients renowned for their cleaning power and eco-friendly properties. Plus, they offer different options based on your preferences, whether you like a fresh scent or prefer no fragrance at all.

Here's a closer look at the ingredients you'll find in each brand's detergent:

Tru Earth Ingredients: Corn Starch, Polyvinyl Alcohol, Glycerin, Sodium C14-16 Olefin Sulfonate, Aqua, Glyceryl Cocoate, Cocamidopropyl Betaine, Caprylyl/Capryl Glucoside, Sodium Gluconate, Fragrance, Paraffinum Liquidum, Potassium Sorbate, Lauryl Glucoside, C10-16 Olefin, Sodium Chloride, and Sodium Sulfate.

*Note - The presence or absence of fragrance is the only difference between their products.

An upclose image of a Tru Earth laundry sheet.
Close-up view of a Tru Earth Laundry Sheet

Earth Breeze Ingredients: Glycerol, Primary Alcohol Ethoxylate, Protease, Sodium Dodecyl Sulfate, Sodium Acetate Trihydrate, Polyvinyl Alcohol, Polyethylene Glycol, Deionized Water, and Corn Starch.

*Note - The presence or absence of essence is only included in the Fresh-scent option.

An upclose image of an Earth Breeze laundry sheet.
Close-up view of an Earth Breeze Laundry Sheet

Tru Earth vs Earth Breeze Price Comparison

When it comes to pricing, consider the upfront cost and the cost per load. This will give you a more accurate picture of the value you're getting. Here's a breakdown of the cost per load for both Tru Earth and Earth Breeze, considering their usage recommendations:

Tru Earth Laundry Strips Pricing

Each package is priced based on the number of strips. One sheet contains two strips, and one strip is suitable for one load.

8 - Standard Strips 4 sheets | 8 loads
Regular Price: $9.95 Price per Load: $1.24 Subscription Price: N/A Subscription Price per Load: N/A
32 - Standard Strips 16 sheets | 32 loads
Regular Price: $19.95 Price per Load: $0.62 Subscription Price: $13.95 Subscription Price per Load: $0.43
64 - Standard Strips 32 sheets | 64 loads
Regular Price: $35.95 Price per Load: $0.56 Subscription Price: $25.90 Subscription Price per Load: $0.40
384 - Standard Strips 192 sheets | 384 loads
Regular Price: $149.00 Price per Load: $0.38 Subscription Price: $119.00 Subscription Price per Load: $0.31
32 - Platinum Strips 16 sheets | 32 loads
Regular Price: $21.95 Price per Load: $0.68 Subscription Price: $15.95 Subscription Price per Load: $0.49
64 - Platinum Strips 32 sheets | 64 loads
Regular Price: $39.95 Price per Load: $0.62 Subscription Price: $28.95 Subscription Price per Load: $0.45
384 - Platinum Strips 192 sheets | 384 loads
Regular Price: $164.00 Price per Load: $0.42 Subscription Price: $130.00 Subscription Price per Load: $0.33

*Tru Earth's Platinum Strips are a heavy-duty laundry detergent formula for more soiled clothing.

Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets Pricing

Earth Breeze Sheets 30 sheets | 60 loads
Regular Price: $20.00 Price per Load: $0.33 Subscription Price: $12.00 Subscription Price per Load: $0.20

Usage Recommendations

  • Tru Earth: 1 strip per standard load (½ drum). Adjust the number of strips based on load size and soil level. Each strip can be torn in half for small loads.
  • Earth Breeze: Half a sheet per standard load (½ drum), a full sheet for a large load (¾ drum), and two sheets for an extra-large or heavily soiled load (full drum).

Sustainability and Company Values

Tru Earth: Community and Environment First

Tru Earth is actively involved in community upliftment and environmental conservation. They have strategically placed distribution centers in Washington, Utah, and Tennessee to serve their US customers efficiently. For Canadian customers, you can expect quick deliveries from British Columbia and Ontario.

This setup not only ensures timely deliveries but also minimizes their carbon footprint.

Every $25 spent on any of their products turns into a one-month supply of laundry detergent for individuals who need it most. And they've been quite busy! As of September 2023, over 30 million Tru Earth eco-strips have been donated to over 800 organizations in the United States and Canada.

Each time you buy a pack of their 32-load eco-strips, packaged in plastic-free, compostable, and recyclable material, you prevent one large plastic detergent bottle from ending up in our oceans or landfills.

To date, with the help of their supporters, they have stopped over 160 million jugs from polluting the environment, which is a massive win for Mother Earth!

They're also committed to allocating at least 2% of their revenue to charitable organizations annually. Through these initiatives, they have created a community of over a million eco-warriors across 72 countries, united in the fight against plastic waste.

Earth Breeze: Creating a Positive Impact Through Action

Earth Breeze is a socially responsible company that gives back to communities and protects the environment. Their main headquarters and warehouses are in Medford, Oregon, with another distribution center in the United Kingdom. This allows them to ship products locally, which reduces their carbon footprint while still having a global reach.

Despite their emphasis on local distribution, Earth Breeze manufactures their laundry detergent sheets in China. This manufacturing process contributes to their carbon dioxide emissions from production to distribution. However, Earth Breeze remains committed to offsetting these emissions through various environmentally-friendly initiatives.

These efforts start with their packaging, which, like Tru Earth, is not only plastic-free but also recyclable and can be composted in your garden at home.

In 2020, they launched their Buy One, Give Ten program. For every purchase of their eco sheets, they donate ten loads of laundry to people who are unable to afford it. This initiative has assisted many families and individuals experiencing financial challenges.

But here's what I really love - they let you decide where your donations go!

You can directly support homeless shelters, animal shelters, women's refuges, or veterans' homes. Additionally, you can send your donations to those affected by global crises and natural disasters.

With a network of 800 partners globally, including 600 in the US, you can support the cause that matters to you the most.

Partnering with groups like We are Neutral and 1% for the Planet, Earth Breeze participates in carbon offset projects and donates one percent of their annual sales back to environmental organizations.

They're also dedicated to making a difference at the local level. This includes planting trees, cleaning beaches and oceans, and removing plastic from waterways.

To date, they've planted over 150,000 trees, removed 12,000 pounds of plastic from local waterways, and donated over 2 million meals through Feeding America.

Testing Effectiveness: Tru Earth vs. Earth Breeze

Now it's time to put Tru Earth and Earth Breeze to the ultimate test. Below, you'll see how each brand performed, accompanied by before-and-after images to provide a clear picture of what each product can achieve.

How I Tested Each Detergent

I wanted this test to be even for both detergents, so I used them according to the instructions on their packaging for a standard load. The washing machine settings remained the same for both tests using cold water.

To ensure they were tested on the same fabric, I grabbed two old 100% cotton white t-shirts and deliberately stained them with dirt, coffee, and grass. These stains would give any laundry detergent a run for its money, so why not challenge them both and see what happens?

I let the shirts sit for an hour to let the stains set in before washing them in two separate loads.

Let's take a look at the results!

How Tru Earth's Laundry Strips Performed

Tru Earth packaging and detergent sheet on table

Tru Earth's laundry sheets come in squares with a perforated center line to tear off a strip. I wanted to use the amount they recommended for a standard load, so I only used one strip (half a sheet) for this test. The package does recommend using an entire sheet for larger loads, but I was only filling up my drum about halfway. As a side note, I also used their Lilac Breeze scent for this test to see how strong it would be coming out of the wash.

Stain Removal Test

Image of a t-shirt before being washed with Tru Earth Laundry Sheets

Before

Image of a t-shirt after being washed with Tru Earth Laundry Sheets

After

While washing, I realized I had purchased the Tru Earth Platinum strips, which are a step above their standard eco-strips in terms of the formulation used. These strips are supposed to work best on heavier, more soiled loads. While I was happy with how this shirt came out, there were still signs of grass, dirt, and coffee. I know these stains are tough to get out, but I expected better results based on this being their platinum option.

Score: 7.0/10

Scent and Freshness Test

Post-wash, the clothes were fresh and smelled clean. I was surprised by how mild the lilac scent was. I prefer milder scents, so I was worried it would be overbearing, but it wasn't. If you're like me and prefer a softer, more natural fragrance with your laundry, you might want to give this lilac-scented detergent a try.

Score: 8.5/10

Suds and Residue Test

Tru Earth Eco-strip on top of laundry in washing machine.

I placed the strip directly on top of my laundry

An image showing the inside of washing machine while using Tru Earth Eco-Strips.

What it looked like mid-wash

No suds were seen during the wash, which is what I was expecting, and no residue was left on any of my clothes after washing. As you can see in the mid-wash image, the strip did its job breaking down and provided the wash with enough detergent to be noticeable.

Score: 10/10

Overall

Overall, the Tru Earth laundry strip did a good job. It removed most of the stains, leaving only minor traces of the grass, dirt, and coffee stains. I was disappointed that the platinum version didn't remove them completely, but using a whole sheet or a pre-wash treatment might fix that.

I enjoyed the mild scent, and the clothes felt fresh. So, if you're into light fragrances, you'll love these. Plus, no residue was left on the clothes – they were just clean and fresh!

I recommend giving Tru Earth laundry strips a try. They're easy to use, effective, and environmentally friendly. They simplify the laundry process, providing a mess-free and hassle-free experience. They're a smart choice for anyone looking to make their laundry routine greener!

Overall Score: 8.5/10


How Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets Performed

Earth Breeze packaging and detergent sheet on table

The Earth Breeze laundry sheets also come in squares, and the packaging says to use half a sheet for a standard load of laundry. Unlike Tru Earth, these sheets don't have a perforated line in the center to quickly tear them in half. Tearing the sheet wasn't an issue, but it meant I had to be careful to try and only use half a sheet. For the scent, I chose their fresh scent option over their fragrance-free option to compare them to Tru Earth's scented sheets.

Stain Removal Test

Image of a t-shirt before being washed with Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets

Before

Image of a t-shirt after being washed with Earth Breeze Laundry Sheets

After

I was pleasantly surprised by how well the Earth Breeze shirt turned out. What impressed me the most was that Earth Breeze's standard option worked just as well as Tru Earth's platinum option, if not better. Although some grass and coffee stains were still on the shirt, Earth Breeze's sheet completely removed the dirt stain that Tru Earth couldn't. It worked perfectly on my other clothes, but adding a full sheet may have helped remove more of the tougher stains.

Score: 9.0/10

Scent and Freshness Test

Before transferring the clothes from this load into the dryer, I took a quick sniff to see what their fresh scent was all about. Just like Tru Earth's, the scent was very mild, and I actually had to bring the shirt up to my nose to smell anything. Some may like a little more of a scent to their clothes, but this was just fine for me. After drying, the shirt and the other clothes in the load looked clean and fresh.

Score: 9.0/10

Suds and Residue Test

Earth Breeze laundry sheet on top of laundry in washing machine.

I placed half a sheet directly on top of my laundry

An image showing the inside of washing machine while using Earth Breeze's laundry detergent sheets.

What it looked like mid-wash

The Earth Breeze sheet did exactly what it was supposed to do. I put it in the washing machine, and it dissolved quickly without any problems. When the wash was done, my clothes were clean, and there wasn't any leftover residue from the sheet. It was simple, hassle-free, and effective!

Score: 10/10

Overall

Based on my experience, the Earth Breeze laundry sheets are legit and can rival many of the traditional detergents. Although it still left a little to be desired on the hard-to-clean grass and coffee stains, it surpassed my expectations by completely removing the dirt stain.

It didn't produce any suds and left no residue on the clothes, living up to their promise of a clean, residue-free wash.

Overall, this test showed me that the Earth Breeze laundry sheets are a reliable and legitimate eco-friendly choice for laundry. It blends effectiveness with environmental consciousness and will leave your clothes smelling incredibly fresh and clean.

Overall Score: 9.3/10


The Head-to-Head Winner

Both brands exceeded my expectations with how clean my clothes came out. Still, there are a couple of noticeable differences that you should consider to figure out exactly which brand is best for you. Let's take a look at the final results.

Criteria Tru Earth Earth Breeze
Ingredients
Stain Removal
Ease of Use
Freshness
Sustainability
Price

Ingredients

When it comes to the ingredients, it's clear that both Tru Earth and Earth Breeze make significant efforts to use eco-friendly components. However, there is a difference between the two. Tru Earth contains Paraffinum Liquidum, which is a petroleum-derived mineral oil. On the other hand, Earth Breeze uses mostly natural ingredients that are less harmful to aquatic life. Looking at the ingredients alone, Earth Breeze can be considered a more eco-friendly option than Tru Earth.

Stain Removal

The most significant difference between the two is their stain-removal capabilities. The fact that half an Earth Breeze sheet did just as much, plus more, as the "platinum" strip from Tru Earth speaks volumes.

The sheet from Earth Breeze was able to remove the dirt stain from the test, which Tru Earth's strip couldn't do. Given the price difference, I expected better results from the Tru Earth wash. Because of this, Earth Breeze takes this category.

However, both brands exceeded my expectations with how well they performed on the stains using cold water. As you can see from the before and after pictures above, they both delivered outstanding results considering the limitations set. Either would be an excellent choice for your day-to-day laundry needs.

Ease of Use

Tru Earth's perforated design makes them more convenient to use. Because their strips can easily be torn in half, I didn't need to worry about having enough of the sheet left over for another load like I did with Earth Breeze. I can see situations where I would use an entire sheet from Earth Breeze instead of taking the time to tear it perfectly in half.

Freshness and Scent

Both brands were on par in terms of scents and freshness. However, Tru Earth might be more up your alley if you want an eco-friendly detergent that offers a little more fragrance. On the other hand, if you prefer a near fragrance-free experience, Earth Breeze would be the recommended choice.

Company Sustainability Initiatives

When it comes to sustainability, both Earth Breeze and Tru Earth are making commendable efforts to provide products that are not only effective but also environmentally responsible.

Their commitments to biodegradability, recyclable packaging, and programs that give back to communities and nature showcase their dedication to creating a healthier planet. As a consumer, choosing either brand would be a step in the right direction towards a more sustainable future.

However, I prefer less emissions in the total business model, so I'm giving Tru Earth the nod here. Your choice depends on your preferences and values, as both brands offer a green and responsible choice for your laundry needs.

Choice Based on Cost and Value

Earth Breeze emerges as a more budget-friendly option, especially with its subscription model priced at $0.20 USD per standard load. This represents a significant saving compared to the lowest subscription price per standard load from Tru Earth, which stands at $0.31 USD for their standard strips and $0.33 USD for their platinum strips.

Note - The actual cost-effectiveness might vary based on specific laundry needs (load size, soil level, etc.).

The Verdict

Considering all these factors, the Earth Breeze laundry detergent sheets edge out ahead of Tru Earth's laundry strips in this head-to-head matchup. Its superior stain removal capabilities and cost-effectiveness make it our top choice for those seeking an eco-friendly laundry solution. However, Tru Earth remains a strong contender, especially for those who value ease of use and are willing to invest more for their eco-friendly laundry needs.

What Customers Are Saying - Pros and Cons

Tru Earth Eco-Strips

  • Options for Different Soil Levels
  • Highly Effective in Removing Stains and Dirt
  • Easy-to-Use with No Mess or Measuring
  • Suitable for Individuals with Sensitive Skin
  • Effectively Tackles Tough Pet-Related Stains
  • High Pricing Concerns for International Customers
  • Inconsistent Experience with Fragrance Strength
  • Subscription Service Management Issues

Earth Breeze Eco-Sheets

  • Eco-friendly and Biodegradable Packaging
  • Convenient and Space-saving
  • Enhances Fabric Softness and Brightness
  • Easy-to-Use and Travel-Friendly
  • Affordable Pricing and Subscription Options
  • Sheets Sometimes Do Not Dissolve Properly
  • Lack of Listed Ingredients on Their Website
  • Concerns Regarding its Manufacturing in China

Alternatives to Earth Breeze and Tru Earth

Although Earth Breeze and Tru Earth are often the centers of conversation in the eco-friendly laundry detergent landscape, it's worth noting that other brands are making a name for themselves. Let's have a look at some of these other noteworthy contenders.

Frey Laundry Detergent Sheets

Frey's Laundry Detergent Sheets

4.73 (202 reviews)

If you're looking for a laundry detergent sheet made in the United States, then Frey's laundry detergent sheets are an excellent choice. A notable player in the green laundry market, they rival other brands in cleaning power while prioritizing environmental conservation.

Frey brings a breath of fresh air to your laundry routine with three popular scents: the forest-inspired Cedar Grove, the beachy Bergamot Beach, and the floral Jasmine Meadow.

They also offer a fragrance-free option, all crafted with natural and plant-based ingredients that are kind to both your skin and the planet.

Dropps Dissolvable Laundry Pods

Dropps Dissolvable Laundry Pods

Dropps brings a refreshing and responsible approach to laundry with its innovative pods. These pods are encased in a water-soluble membrane made from Polyvinyl alcohol (PVOH), which dissolves upon contact with water, ensuring safety for your family and the environment.

Infused with natural enzymes and plant-based ingredients, these pods are a sustainable choice that eliminates tough stains and odors. They leave your clothes smelling clean and fresh, and they're gentle on fabrics, making them a reliable choice for all types of clothing.

Blueland Eco-Friendly Powdered Laundry Detergent

Blueland's Tablet Detergent

Blueland is another noteworthy brand offering eco-friendly cleaning solutions.

Their laundry collection, in particular, stands out for its innovative approach. They offer laundry tablets that effortlessly dissolve in water, ensuring a seamless and sustainable laundry experience.

Blueland emphasizes a zero-waste philosophy by housing their products in reusable containers that can be refilled. This not only reduces waste but also promotes a sustainable lifestyle.



About the Author

Brett Knighton, Owner of GreenLifeResource.com

Brett Knighton

I am the proud owner of GreenLifeResource.com, a platform dedicated to promoting sustainable living and environmental consciousness. My journey towards sustainability was inspired by my daughter's love for nature and being outdoors. Through her, I realized the importance of preserving the environment not just for her, but for all children. Today, I share my knowledge and experiences, hoping to inspire others to join me in making more environmentally-friendly choices. My goal is to bring families and friends closer together through shared respect and care for our planet.